Backtest Truth, Part 1: Why a Clean Chart Can Invent Profit
A beginner look at fake fills. One Renko test showed +929% on brick prices, then lost about 72% to 99% when real candle prices were used.
Category
Plain-language lessons on how a trading test can mislead, before any money is at risk.
A beginner look at fake fills. One Renko test showed +929% on brick prices, then lost about 72% to 99% when real candle prices were used.
Fees of 0.07% and 0.10% per side changed the same rules from about +245% to about +178% in 2 years, and from about +77% to about +8% on older data.
Tests with no stop showed drawdowns of about 35% to 48%. One rule held a single open trade for 355 days and ignored 21 opposite signals.
One rule made about +22% in the last year, then lost about 27% over 2 years. A stronger setup was about +77% on 2020–2024 data, with a 65% drawdown.
At 2% risk, one test made about +23% in a year with an 18% drawdown. The same family all-in made about +11%, and a strong setup still saw a 65% drawdown on older data.